From Mortgage Origins to Real Estate Innovation: Todd Carpenter - Senior Vice President, Industry Relations, Styldod

The salient point of our discussion with Todd Carpenter revolves around the transformative nature of social media and technological advancements within the real estate industry, particularly in relation to compliance and image management. I elucidate how Todd has significantly contributed to bridging the gap between emerging technologies and real estate practices, particularly through his current role at Styldod. We delve into the intricacies of how artificial intelligence is revolutionizing image editing processes and compliance measures within Multiple Listing Services (MLS). Furthermore, Todd shares invaluable insights from his extensive career, detailing the evolution of social media's role in real estate and the imperative of fostering genuine connections in this competitive industry. This episode serves as a profound exploration of the intersection between technology and real estate, highlighting Todd's expertise and forward-thinking perspective.
A profound exploration of Todd Carpenter's journey through the real estate landscape unfolds in this episode, revealing the intricate interplay between technology, social media, and industry dynamics. The conversation ranges from Carpenter's early influences in the real estate sector, rooted in familial connections, to his pivotal role at the National Association of Realtors, where he championed the integration of social media as a means of fostering communication and mitigating public criticism during challenging times. His anecdotal experiences highlight the evolution of the industry, especially in the face of technological advancements and shifting consumer expectations.
The dialogue further delves into Carpenter's transition to Styldod, a company leveraging artificial intelligence for compliance in real estate listings. With a keen focus on the challenges faced by Multiple Listing Services (MLS) regarding image compliance, Carpenter elucidates how Styldod's innovative solutions not only alleviate the burdens of compliance but also enhance the aesthetic representation of properties. This episode serves as a testament to the ongoing evolution of real estate practices, emphasizing the necessity for agents to adapt to emerging technologies while maintaining a strong network of professional relationships.
Listeners are offered a glimpse into Carpenter's personal philosophy regarding the importance of connections in the real estate industry, as he encourages new agents to prioritize relationship-building over mere transactional interactions. His insights illuminate the significance of leveraging one's sphere of influence to foster success, showcasing a holistic approach to real estate that transcends conventional sales tactics and underscores the human element of the profession.
Takeaways:
- In our conversation, we explored the profound impact of social media on real estate, particularly emphasizing the necessity for leadership and volunteers to effectively engage with negativity and criticism.
- Todd Carpenter elaborated on his extensive career trajectory, highlighting his unique entry into real estate, informed by his family's background in the industry.
- The discussion encompassed the evolution of technology in real estate, notably Todd's insights on how artificial intelligence is transforming compliance and image enhancement for listings.
- We delved into the intricacies of compliance challenges faced by MLSs, emphasizing how emerging technologies can preemptively address these issues before they escalate.
- Todd shared his experiences at the National Association of Realtors, focusing on the need for a cultural shift towards embracing social media as a vital communication tool within the organization.
- The episode culminated in Todd's current role at Styldod, where he is at the forefront of integrating AI technology to streamline real estate image compliance and enhance property presentations.
00:00 - None
00:00 - The Role of Social Media in Leadership
05:20 - The Journey into Real Estate
09:20 - The Rise of Blogging in Real Estate
16:08 - The Rise of Social Media in Real Estate
28:01 - Transitioning to Data-Driven Strategies at NAR
35:29 - Innovations in Real Estate Technology
45:17 - Networking and Building Relationships in Real Estate
We spent a tremendous amount of time talking about social media and teaching people how to do social media, especially the leadership team and the volunteers and how to respond to negativity.
Speaker AAnd I would be kind of like put at the forefront and have to be an example for how to do this and take some of the hits.
Speaker BYou're listening to the Real Estate Sessions and I'm your host, Bill risser.
Speaker BWith nearly 25 years in the real estate business, I love to interview industry leaders, up and comers, and really anyone with a story to tell.
Speaker BIt's the stories that led my guests to a career in the real estate world that drives me in my 10th year and over 400 episodes of the podcast.
Speaker BAnd now I hope you enjoy the next journey.
Speaker BHi, everybody.
Speaker BWelcome to episode 414 of the Real Estate Sessions podcast.
Speaker BAs always, thank you so much for tuning in.
Speaker BThank you much for telling a friend.
Speaker BI'm happy to have a new episode for you this week.
Speaker BEven happier that it's Todd Carpenter, somebody that I've known for a long time, going back to the, oh, blogging days, that's how long ago.
Speaker BHe's now senior vice president of industry relations with styledod.
Speaker BWe're gonna talk to him about that.
Speaker BThey're doing some really cool stuff with images and mlss and compliance.
Speaker BI'll just leave it at that.
Speaker BYou need to listen to this.
Speaker BIt's really good.
Speaker BAnd we go take a walk through, like, memory lane about some of the things that were really important like 12 years ago that don't matter so much today.
Speaker BThat's funny how that stuff works, but it's a lot of fun.
Speaker BThank you so much for joining us.
Speaker BLet's get this thing started.
Speaker BTodd, welcome to the podcast.
Speaker AIt's great to be here, Bill.
Speaker AIt's good to see you again.
Speaker AIt's been a while.
Speaker BIt has been a while.
Speaker BAnd boy, there were some fun times back in the day.
Speaker BI think you, you're a part of that original re.net that was exploding around the country early in the OR.
Speaker BI'd say 2005, 6, 7.
Speaker BIt was pretty fun.
Speaker BAnd I know that you spend a lot of time in Chicagoland now because, you know, you had some, a couple of different stints at nar.
Speaker BBut I have to be really brutally honest, Todd, I do not know where you grew up.
Speaker BI just always associated you with the Midwest.
Speaker BSo where was home for you?
Speaker BWhere'd you grow up?
Speaker ASo, yeah, I grew up in the suburbs of Denver, Colorado, which is still my favorite state.
Speaker ABut my wife is from the Midwest.
Speaker AAnd I love my wife, so we live in the Midwest.
Speaker BThat makes, that makes a lot of sense.
Speaker BGrowing up in Denver.
Speaker BDid you go to high school there?
Speaker BWas it.
Speaker BWere you there that long?
Speaker AOh, yeah, yeah.
Speaker AI started my career in Denver.
Speaker AI briefly moved to California around 2000, but most of my life up until Chicago was in Denver.
Speaker BOkay, and a couple questions.
Speaker BDoes that mean you're a Broncos fan?
Speaker AOh, absolutely.
Speaker AAnd after a very, you know, growing up, I was used to having a football team that won all the time, because the Broncos, from the 80s until, you know, about 10 years ago, they were up until Super Bowl 50, they were one of the winningest teams in the league and it's been pretty rough.
Speaker ABut we got Bo Nicks now and the future is looking better.
Speaker AAt least that's.
Speaker BI was at the Broncos win over the packers in San Diego.
Speaker BSo yeah, that was.
Speaker BI think the Broncos won that one.
Speaker BYeah, they did.
Speaker BI don't think of Denver as like a sports town, but man, it's exploded.
Speaker BYou got the Nuggets, you got the.
Speaker BGot the Avalanche.
Speaker BNow you've got the.
Speaker BThe.
Speaker BHelp me out with the other one.
Speaker BThe.
Speaker AThe Rockies.
Speaker BThe Purple Team.
Speaker BThe Rockies.
Speaker AThe Rockies.
Speaker AYeah, you know, it.
Speaker AIt was always a sports town.
Speaker AHe lived there.
Speaker AIt's similar to like Boston where on.
Speaker AMy wife.
Speaker AMy wife, when we lived there for a year, commented that the best time to go shopping was Sunday at 2:00 because literally everyone in the city watched the games.
Speaker AAnd in fact, even it drew the Avalanche there because the minor league team that was playing had bigger audiences than like seven NHL teams because it was so popular.
Speaker AAnd then when the baseball expanded, they had like the major league baseball executives were in the city to interview the people that wanted to bring the Rockies there or start the new organization.
Speaker AAnd something like 30,000 people showed up outside to chant like, take me out to the ball game.
Speaker AJust to tell people.
Speaker AAnd then of course, the first year the Rockies played, they played it at the Bronco Stadium, which seats like 70,000 people and they were drawing 70,000 people to those games.
Speaker AThey set the all time league attendance record for a single season and it's doubtful that will ever be eclipsed.
Speaker ASo it's definitely a sports town for sure.
Speaker BThat's cool.
Speaker BI've had a chance to go to an all star game there.
Speaker BI took my son.
Speaker BThis was 98, I think it was in Denver.
Speaker BAnd that Loto or downtown area is just really cool.
Speaker BI mean, it's got some neat stuff.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BBig fan, big fan of the city.
Speaker BNot so much the teams, because I was in San Diego at the time, so we'll just move on.
Speaker BSo you talked about, you know, you moved around a little bit for work, out of school.
Speaker BTodd was real estate the first thing you were thinking about?
Speaker BWas that where you were headed or was it something else?
Speaker AWell, it wasn't, but, you know, my mom was a real estate agent, so I was.
Speaker AI was born into the industry, I like to say.
Speaker AMy booster seat literally was an MLS book that I would sit on when I was a little kid.
Speaker AAnd I knew how to change a combination on those lockboxes.
Speaker AYou know, when I was like 12 years old or something, she got into mortgages.
Speaker AAnd honestly, you know, like, I know most of your audience is going to recognize this.
Speaker ALike, real estate's really hard, and there's good times and bad times.
Speaker AI mostly remember the bad times.
Speaker AAnd I swear to myself, I would never take a commission sales job because you have those ups and downs and it's.
Speaker AIt can be frustrating.
Speaker ASo I wanted to be an auto mechanic, of all things.
Speaker BOkay.
Speaker AWhile I was going to school, I got a job at the Sears Auto center.
Speaker AAnd I wanted, you know, usually you start out like busting tires or something like that, but they didn't have any of those positions open, and they put me on the front desk.
Speaker AAnd so about two years in, I realized I'm making more money than almost anyone in the building selling stuff, and realized I was actually a pretty decent salesperson.
Speaker AAnd so now it's.
Speaker AAnd I'm dating myself.
Speaker ABut now it's 1991, and the biggest refi boom of all time is happening.
Speaker AYou know, today people complain about the rates being in the sevens, but in 1990, the rates were in the 13s, and so we're refinancing people down to like eight, and it's, you know, saving them hundreds of dollars.
Speaker ASo my.
Speaker AMy mom basically says, look, you should finish school.
Speaker ABut on the other hand, I know you can do this and you should come do it.
Speaker AAnd so I worked for her for a year as a loan officer.
Speaker AAnd then I didn't love working for my mom.
Speaker AI love my mom, but I didn't love working for her.
Speaker ASo I went to work with another company and originated loans for several years.
Speaker AEventually I got into wholesale mortgage.
Speaker AAnd then in 2000, I went to work for a startup in San Jose, California, called Myers Internet, and they were eventually bought by mgic.
Speaker AThey built websites for loan officers and some real estate agents.
Speaker AAnd the big thing about it is it had like an Online loan application form.
Speaker AAnd that was the craziest thing of all time.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AWe also did Internet leads where people would come in and they would just fill out this.
Speaker AYou know, a loan application has a lot of private information on it, and they just like randomly fill them out.
Speaker AAnd then we'd sell Those leads for 50 bucks each to several mortgage brokers.
Speaker AIt was kind of a crazy time before there was, you know, an understanding of loan or, like, identity fraud or things like that.
Speaker ASo obviously it's a lot more secure now.
Speaker ABut that was my first taste of startup technology.
Speaker ABut yeah, and so then, you know, after a.
Speaker AWorked there, I came back to Denver and got back into wholesale.
Speaker ABut the banks I worked for, they didn't really get technology either at that point.
Speaker AThe Internet is still kind of new, and they had these really complicated websites, and if your customer just wanted to download like a rate lock form or a cover letter form or something like that, some simple form that doesn't have any private information, they would have to go to the bank website and log in with their ID and find it.
Speaker AAnd, you know, it was very complicated.
Speaker ASo I created this website called lenderama for my 50 clients that basically just mostly just had forms that they could download that was so much easier for them to do.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAnd that's sort of how my first website was ever born.
Speaker AAnd then eventually I turned it into a blog.
Speaker ASo.
Speaker ASo did that get you.
Speaker BDid that.
Speaker BThat takes you up into the time where social starts happening as well, Right?
Speaker BBecause that's.
Speaker BBecause that's your.
Speaker BIt feels like that's the.
Speaker BThat was your entrance into NAR, for sure.
Speaker ASo, yeah, actually, you know, it was 2005 when I launched that blog.
Speaker AThat was still four years before I went to NAR.
Speaker ABut the.
Speaker AThe premise of the blogging was really based on how successful some conservative bloggers had been in discounting 60 minutes during the election the year before.
Speaker AAnd there was a story that 60 Minutes had about George Bush not fulfilling his National Guard duty.
Speaker AAnd it turns out within a couple of days, these conservative bloggers had figured out that some of the evidence had been.
Speaker AHad been mocked up.
Speaker ALike there was some letter that was supposedly typed in the 60s or 70s, I guess, and it had been printed with Microsoft Word, so it obviously was fake.
Speaker ASo, you know, I wasn't really like, I didn't want to have a political blog, but I was really impressed that this new technology had sort of shifted.
Speaker ABecause you think about 60 Minutes, that's like the.
Speaker AAlmost like the most authoritative news broadcast there is.
Speaker AAnd here these guys, you know, I think an executive of CBS said, oh, some guy in their pajamas in their basement writing, writing a blog.
Speaker AAnd I thought, well, I have pajamas and I have a basement.
Speaker AI could start writing this.
Speaker AAnd so I start writing this blog for mortgage officers that's part of my website and it becomes my website.
Speaker AAnd I thought, oh yeah, the, you know, I have like 50 mortgage brokers who are my clients and if, if 20 of them read this, it'll help me.
Speaker AIt's a one way just to stay in contact with them.
Speaker ABut eventually I was getting two or three thousand unique visitors a day and it was only a site that loan officers would read.
Speaker AIt's like, here's a blog post about how to get approved for FHA loans or to track the LIBOR for adjustable rate mortgages or things like that.
Speaker ASo I suddenly sort of became a social media expert just because I was one of the very first people to do.
Speaker BSounds like the Jay Thompson story a little bit as well, right, Jay?
Speaker BAbout the same time, yeah.
Speaker AYou know, and so one of the things I did is I started looking for other blogs.
Speaker ASo right when I started, only a couple weeks later, I found loan officer Dan Green had a blog called the Mortgage Reports.
Speaker AAnd I was like, how is there already another mortgage blog?
Speaker AI thought I was the first one.
Speaker AAnd we had started almost like on the same day.
Speaker AAnd I was like.
Speaker ABut the real estate was sort of lent itself to blogging more than mortgages.
Speaker ABecause I feel like people that get into mortgages generally have more of like math based mind.
Speaker AAnd people who get into selling real estate have more of a creative based mind.
Speaker AAnd there's plenty of examples where that's the opposite.
Speaker ABut you just have to be more creative.
Speaker AI think when you're working with customers and showing them a home.
Speaker AAnd it's not just the simple math.
Speaker AYou'll save $250 if you refinance at this rate, blah, blah, blah.
Speaker AAnd so I started looking for real estate blogs and Jay was one of the very first ones.
Speaker AI found someone else who's been on your show, Inez Higuettis Garcia.
Speaker AShe was one of the earliest ones.
Speaker AJim Duncan, who is one of the co founders of Nest, great real estate brokerage, he was one of the earliest ones.
Speaker ASo there was quite a few of us.
Speaker AAnd that still kind of predated social media as we know it.
Speaker AThere was just bloggers.
Speaker AThere were a lot of bloggers out there.
Speaker BActive Rain was, it comes to mind.
Speaker AActive Rain, that all popped up and I met Quite a few other people throughout through that network as well.
Speaker BYeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker ASo it was sort of an evolution to real estate because I had just decided I should track who else is doing this.
Speaker AAnd then in 2007, there was two bloggers out of New York, Joe Ferreira and Rudy Bachrati.
Speaker AAnd they had a blog called the Celsius Blog.
Speaker AAnd they.
Speaker AThey were going to go to Inman Connect in San Francisco, but they decided they were going to do this tour across America and try to find all the other bloggers that were out there and meet with them.
Speaker AAnd they rented an RV and put a bunch of sponsorship stickers on it, and they were going to come through Denver.
Speaker ASo I reached out to them and I was like, well, what do you have planned for Denver?
Speaker AAnd they're like, well, why don't you plan something?
Speaker AAnd so I built my very first real estate event.
Speaker AIt was called Blog Fiesta.
Speaker AIt was in a.
Speaker ABecause I found a cheap space in a Mexican restaurant in the Tech center in Denver.
Speaker AAnd we had tacos and talked about blogging.
Speaker AAnd at that event, Crystal Craft, are you familiar with her?
Speaker AShe was a blogger in Denver and she really helped me reach out to all the other bloggers, especially on Active Rain, that were in the area.
Speaker AAnd I think like 30, 40 people showed up to this.
Speaker AJoe and Rudy were kind of blown away.
Speaker AIt was like the biggest event up until San Francisco.
Speaker AAnd then we all went to.
Speaker AA lot of us went to San Francisco and Inman had created an event called Beer for Bloggers.
Speaker AAnd it was just like all the people.
Speaker AThis is still like before social media really is hitting.
Speaker ABut there was like a lot of the early people at Zolo, like Drew Myers and David Gibbons were there, and I met Nicole Nicolay there, and I met Dan Green in person there.
Speaker AAnd Jim Duncan, like just mentioned Dustin Luther.
Speaker AAnd so that sort of became like the beginning of that re net that you talked about.
Speaker AAnd Jay.
Speaker AI met Jay.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker AAnd so that was sort of.
Speaker AI got the taste for doing events I still hadn't really even thought about, like, nar.
Speaker ABut then I met up with another real estate person, or not, sorry, mortgage person, his name's Jason Berman.
Speaker AAnd we decided to create our own technology event because really, like real estate tech, mortgage tech, none of that was about social media at all.
Speaker ANo one knew how to address this.
Speaker AThis is all so new.
Speaker ASo we were going to have an event in Tag along with a bigger event called Blog World in Vegas.
Speaker AAnd while we were planning that event, another friend of mine, Andy Kaufman, he came up with this idea for Re Bar Camp.
Speaker AAnd so we jumped right into that and started helping him with that.
Speaker AAnd all this was 2007, 2008.
Speaker BThis is really cool.
Speaker BI'm just sitting here just reminiscing.
Speaker BAnd me, I actually went to a Blog World event in Vegas because Nick Bastian was going to be there, and Jay Thompson and Dean Willett, and this was all the Phoenix guys that were, you know, trying to do the same things.
Speaker BIt was very interesting times.
Speaker BDo you see an opening at nar, or does NAR reach out to you?
Speaker AHow does that happen?
Speaker AYou know, it's pretty funny because while we were promoting Reblog World, man, putting on events that people pay for is.
Speaker AIs very difficult, especially when you're doing the very first one.
Speaker AAnd so literally, it was like hand to hand combat.
Speaker AWe were reaching out to people.
Speaker AIf they left a comment on the blog or mentioned Ari, Blog World or any of that stuff, we would reach out.
Speaker AAnd one of the people that had.
Speaker AShe had come to the site in one way or another was a lady named Hilary Marsh.
Speaker AAnd she worked at nar.
Speaker AAnd so I connected with her and I was trying to get her to come to the conference.
Speaker AAnd she ran the.
Speaker AAt the time, it was called realtor.org, it was the, you know, the main website for narrative.
Speaker ASo I sort of knew her, but not very well.
Speaker AAnd then on monster.com, nAR listed that they were looking for a social media manager.
Speaker AAnd I was like, man, who do I know?
Speaker ALike, instead of applying through Monster, I was like, who do I know at nar?
Speaker AI know Hilary Marsh.
Speaker ASo I reached out to Hillary and I'm like, what do you know about this job?
Speaker AI'm interested.
Speaker AAnd she's like, I'm the one hiring for it.
Speaker AAnd so almost like from day one, I had inside path to get that job.
Speaker AAnd it was very weird because up until then, I still saw myself as a mortgage guy, mostly talking about mortgage.
Speaker AAnd so now, just because I had been doing it longer than anyone else, I'd become like, this social media expert.
Speaker ABut it was really, like, only to facilitate the mortgage side.
Speaker ABut at that point, I knew if I took a job at the national association of Realtors, I was gonna meet, like, a tremendous number of people I was gonna open a lot of.
Speaker AAnd so I campaigned really hard for that position, and I moved to Chicago in order to do it.
Speaker AToday's, like, remote world was not really existence back then.
Speaker AEveryone worked in the office, and so it was just like a tremendous opportunity.
Speaker ABecause one, I was there to sort of like, evangelize social media to agents.
Speaker AAnd the reason being for that was that the communications team wanted more agents, more members to be vocal about their market.
Speaker AAnd remember, this is like, right after the housing downturn is really hitting 2008, 2009.
Speaker AAnd so the press is talking terribly about our industry, and rightly so in some cases, but they wanted more voices about what's going on in local markets all across the country.
Speaker AAnd what better way than to leverage over a million people that are passionate about this and people who know their markets.
Speaker AAnd so we spent a tremendous amount of time talking about social media and teaching people how to do social media, especially like the leadership team and the volunteers and how to respond to negativity.
Speaker AAnd I would be.
Speaker AI would be kind of like, put at the forefront and, like, have to be an example for, you know, how to do this and take.
Speaker ATake some of the hits.
Speaker ASimilar to Jay Thompson when he went to Zillow, and, you know, you're kind of like the one getting punched, but that was fine.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker ABut then the back end was to train all of the staff, especially on how to use social media, because NAR at that point was very much like a command and control type communication.
Speaker AThey were.
Speaker AI mean, they literally were speaking from an ivory tower at the time.
Speaker AThere was no ability for the members to kind of like, talk back in public.
Speaker AAnd suddenly this social media thing popped up and, you know, again, Jay Thompson had created a blog called NAR Wisdom, and it was very critical of nar.
Speaker ASome of the, you know, like, NAR had sponsored a giant Rose bowl float right during the housing downturn.
Speaker AAnd, you know, there was.
Speaker AThere were a lot of like.
Speaker ABut suddenly they weren't used to, like, this public criticism.
Speaker AWhat do you do about it?
Speaker AAnd now I feel like it's sort of native to everyone to understand how online criticism happens.
Speaker ABut it was very new to them.
Speaker ASo it was a lot.
Speaker AThere was an internal side and an external side to that job.
Speaker BI'll bet you some of those conversations were pretty rough.
Speaker BI would just think internally, even right where you're trying to say, look, we can't.
Speaker BWe can't attack.
Speaker BWe can't do this, we can't do that.
Speaker BWe've got to be, you know, we've got to find this.
Speaker BThis place where we're taking care of those people, because those people are members, even though they're criticizing, you know, and.
Speaker AWhat was interesting about it was that there were many departments at NAR who were wanted to use the social media because they could break out of whatever the official line of what the NAR community communications team was saying.
Speaker ALike they would be able to get their message out on their own without, without that command and control.
Speaker AAnd so the communications team, which is where I was, was actually like the most anti social media of any department there because they were losing control of what they had always had control of before, which is totally understandable.
Speaker ASo that there were a lot of internal politics where I luckily had the endorsement of the CEO Dale Sitton at the time.
Speaker ALike he had made clear, like we're going to do what Todd thinks about this stuff.
Speaker ABut it was kind of almost adversarial in some instances because people just weren't used to this new force and the two way conversation.
Speaker ALuckily my boss Hillary, she got it, she understood it, but there were other folks there that just were totally uncomfortable with it at that, at that point.
Speaker BThere's in, in your timeline, you decide to go back to Denver, we'll call it, and, and, and work with Trulia, which at the time, this is still, we'll call it early days.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BI mean this is, they're not a part of Zillow at this time, are they?
Speaker BYet?
Speaker ANo.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BSo they're doing their own thing.
Speaker BPeter's trying to get Spencer or whatever, they're trying, whatever their, the battles were.
Speaker BBut you, it wasn't on the social side, was it, was it more data driven at this point or was this come a little bit later?
Speaker ASo it was the year that they IPO'd, so they were right there about to become a unicorn.
Speaker AAnd it was also a time when both Zillow and Trulia were very unpopular for some of their, some of their practices about how they put up listings and how they attributed listing agents.
Speaker AAnd there was a lot, a lot of angst.
Speaker AAnd of course investors don't like angst.
Speaker ASo I was basically put on a team.
Speaker AI mean literally we're like the listing security team.
Speaker AWe're trying to make sure the brokers are still giving us listings.
Speaker AAnd I was leveraging some social media, but a lot of like industry relations type work to connect with big brokers and also a lot of mlss and try to get them to be more aligned.
Speaker AAnd honestly like a lot of it was because we were about to IPO and we were trying to figure that piece out.
Speaker AAnd then after I left, truly was acquired about a year after that from Zillow.
Speaker BOkay, so and then that, that brings you back to nar.
Speaker BNow this for sure, this is A rat.
Speaker BA big change.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker BBecause generally people who are in the communication, social side of stuff.
Speaker BWell, once again, you talked about it would be the creatives.
Speaker BThey're thinking about that stuff.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker BBut you've already laid out for us that you were more of the math guy when you were having success as a lender.
Speaker BSo it kind of makes sense then that back back to nar, you go heavy into the data side of things and really, I mean, that's what a lot of people that they think of you as that only because they've met you, you know, after the truly time.
Speaker BThat time at ner, we got ioi.
Speaker BI mean, there were some really, really cool stuff going on when you were back there.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker ASo Trulia, you know, that just didn't work out.
Speaker AWe were, I was, I was trying to tell them about the right way to do things in the real estate way, and they were focused on the right way to do it in the tech way.
Speaker AAnd you know, ultimately I think they got what they wanted was this acquisition from Zillow.
Speaker ABut when I left, I owe it to Dale Stinton, the CEO, and Mark Les Wing, who was the cto.
Speaker AThey reached back out to me, and while I don't have the data chops or the programming chops to be a data scientist, they did know that I was really good at explaining technology to people who don't understand technology.
Speaker BThere you go.
Speaker AAnd so that guy in the movie Office Space who's like, I'm the one that talks to the engineers.
Speaker AEngineers don't have good people skills.
Speaker AYeah, that's kind of neat.
Speaker AI don't want to jump to conclusions game.
Speaker ABut anyway, yeah, so they had this new initiative, and that initiative was to learn way, way more about their members than they previously did, to use Big Data data science to figure out how they can get people to take more education classes, give more money to the pac, reach out to their senator more often, you know, anything that NAR is trying to do as an organization, it's not even really real estate related.
Speaker AIt was more like member organization.
Speaker AAnd just like social media at the time, Big Data was scary because now we're going to collect a whole bunch of data about these members who might feel like their privacy is being invaded.
Speaker AAnd they needed someone to build that team, but they also needed someone that could sell that.
Speaker AAnd by sell it, I mean sell it to the leadership, the volunteer leadership, the president, the incoming president, and explain why it's, you know, what we're doing is not the same as some of the online retailers today.
Speaker ABut we are collecting this and here's what we're going to do with it.
Speaker AAnd beyond, just like the actions of the association, we were buying data about political persuasion and household income.
Speaker AAnd there was a lot of data, hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of data to, you know, especially to make the advocacy team more effective.
Speaker AAnd they're right.
Speaker AThey're by far one of the most effective advocacy associations in, in America.
Speaker AAnd so it was really more of a sales job.
Speaker AAnd.
Speaker ABut I hired like our original data science team and we had to go to each department at NAR and figure out their systems.
Speaker AA lot of them didn't connect to each other.
Speaker AAnd we had to put all this, what's called the data lake, which is how you can create machine learning and start to build cohorts and algorithms in order to identify who has the highest propensity to get their E Pro certification or whatever and then go sell them that stuff.
Speaker AAnd again, also a difficult transition for the staff to suddenly just do things in a whole different way that they hadn't thought of before.
Speaker ABeing more data driven about all their messaging and things like that.
Speaker ASo similar evangelist role, similar to social media.
Speaker BWhat timeframe are we talking about here?
Speaker BWhen did this get started?
Speaker AI went back in 2013.
Speaker ASo that was.
Speaker BThis is over 10 years ago.
Speaker BYou're talking about stuff that now everyone today kind of knows the term machine learning.
Speaker BYou've heard about it through AI and, you know, and all these other things that are popping out there.
Speaker BYeah, that was a long time ago.
Speaker BThat seems like it was almost like NAR was an early adopter of the strategy that we gotta know, we need data points and we gotta know how to use these.
Speaker BAnd I know, I'm sure there were others that even earlier were doing that, but probably in the real estate space.
Speaker BThis was unheard of at that time.
Speaker AI mean, outside of like CoreLogic or Zillow, there were very few companies with these kind of technology chops.
Speaker AAnd of course, we were doing it on a far smaller budget.
Speaker AI mean, there's only like 300 employees at NAR, and half of them are really more like advocacy people and things like that.
Speaker BSo.
Speaker AYeah, so, but it was sort of a learning experience.
Speaker ABut also, you know, dating back to when I was in mortgages, that first wholesale mortgage job I had, they had this new technology that they had contract.
Speaker AIt was called a company called Washington Mortgage, and they had done a deal with Fannie Mae to be one of the beta testers for this program called Desktop Originator, which is Literally how online.
Speaker AEvery online loan today is running on something similar to this program.
Speaker ABut basically there was a computer program that pre qualified people figured out what their credit risk was.
Speaker AAnd that was sort of my selling point is that I had this new program like the company I worked for sold a lot of vanilla type loans that there was nothing really special about those loans.
Speaker AAnd so if you didn't have the lowest price, it was very hard to get the deals.
Speaker ABut we had this new technology that was getting more people approved for conforming loans and I really adopted it.
Speaker AAnd that was the point where I realized that I was good about talking about technology and pretty much my entire career after that was what is my tech edge.
Speaker AAnd so when we get to this, you know, to the data science piece I was learning on the job, but I already understood enough about it, especially from working at Trulia.
Speaker ATheir AB testing of the website and things like that were amazing for the time.
Speaker AAnd so it's just been, I've always tried to like look ahead, see what is on the on the horizon, determine if it is something that is going to be impactful or not.
Speaker AAnd nothing is like a shiny diamond, but everything has a role.
Speaker AAnd so, and how do you leverage that?
Speaker AAnd then how do you talk to salespeople who are more busy selling homes or originating mortgages than have the time to learn about these things?
Speaker AAnd so yeah that was, that role was really like I knew that that role was only going to last three or four years because eventually I will have, I eventually trained my first hire to know enough about the internal workings of NAR that he almost didn't need me anymore.
Speaker AAnd that's really when, when the new CEO came in, that's when I transitioned over to Second Century Ventures.
Speaker BWhich is, is that, is it a subsidiary of NAR or is it funded by nar?
Speaker BWhat's the exact connection?
Speaker AIt's a, it's a wholly owned subsidiary of Narrow and they originally.
Speaker ASo second century represents the second century of NAR.
Speaker ASo on the 100 year anniversary of NAR, they created a bunch of new initiatives and one of them was this venture capital fund and they are the only provider of funds to that, that this, this subsidiary.
Speaker AAnd the idea was let's we're a not for profit, let's take some of our revenue and put it in a place where it can hopefully make more money.
Speaker ABut also like let's invest in the real estate tech that's out there.
Speaker AOne of the very first investments I love to talk about, I get like, I just did the tiniest bit of credit for it because Constance, who was running Second Century Ventures at the time, she asked me like, what do you think of this company called Docusign?
Speaker AWe're thinking about investing in them.
Speaker AAnd I'm like, docusign's awesome.
Speaker AYou should totally invest in them.
Speaker AAnd then they did.
Speaker AAnd that investment was several years in the making, but turned out to be a fantastic investment.
Speaker AAnd so Second Century Ventures has paid back NAR the initial amount of money that the member dues funded it.
Speaker AAnd it runs completely on its own.
Speaker AIt's still owned by nar, but it doesn't take any member dues.
Speaker AIt generates its own revenue.
Speaker AIt's one of the ways NAR actually makes money as a, that's not non dues related.
Speaker ASo they've invested in several hundred companies at this point.
Speaker AAnd it's also a great way to not have another Zillow, you know, like you Zillow.
Speaker AZillow is this great company and great technology.
Speaker ABut for the longest time there was a massive adversarial relationship between NAR and Zillow.
Speaker AAnd I feel like Dale, who was the former CEO and Bob Goldberg, who helped create Second Century Ventures felt like, hey, we need to align ourselves with these technology companies and not be adversarial with them.
Speaker AIf we get to them early and explain why, you'd really be better off doing it this way, you're still going to succeed, but you're not going to have the, the back and forth of, you know, having so many brokers mad at you.
Speaker BAnd every prop tech company, startup out there now wants, wants in.
Speaker BThey want to be a part of the ioi, they want to be in the pitch battles, they want the exposure.
Speaker BI mean, it's what Second Century's done is impressive.
Speaker BSuper cool.
Speaker BIt's been a lot of fun to watch it.
Speaker ASo, yeah, so when I came onto the team that was 2017 or 18, Bob Goldberg had just become CEO and he wanted to have a conference that was just focused on tech.
Speaker ANot just like the annual conference and have a tech channel, but a tech focused event.
Speaker AAnd so based on all the stuff I had done with Ari Barkamp and Blog World and all those other things a million years ago, they kind of put me in charge of coming up with the concept and thinking up like the pitch battle and all that stuff.
Speaker AAnd then there was a huge team of people to actually execute that first one.
Speaker ABut I was really involved in that in the first place.
Speaker AAnd that was again to try to expand that tent and just have as many tech companies as possible, who.
Speaker AThey don't necessarily need to get NAR's endorsement.
Speaker AThey just want to know what are the best practices of working with the industry and all the politics involved in the industry.
Speaker AAnd so tremendous amount of time was spent with me helping those companies do that.
Speaker BWell, now, Todd, you're with one of those kinds of companies.
Speaker BYou're with Style.
Speaker BDodd.
Speaker BI, I know the basics of what, what the company does.
Speaker BIt's.
Speaker BIt's a big piece of.
Speaker BIt is going to be helping realtors really show off the property in the best way possible.
Speaker BRight, right.
Speaker BI mean, that's what, that's what.
Speaker BThat's ultimately the end result.
Speaker BTell me about joining them.
Speaker BWhat's going on there?
Speaker AYeah, so it's really exciting company for me because it again is, you know, that, that next technology.
Speaker AAnd even before I went to second Century, I was working for.
Speaker AWhen I did the Data project, I was working for Mark Les Wing and he had a lot of his team trying to write papers about emerging technologies.
Speaker AAnd we would publish them on.
Speaker AWe had a team called the center for Realtor Technology at the time, and we would publish these papers through them.
Speaker AAnd I wrote up.
Speaker AIt was 2017 and I wrote a big report.
Speaker AIt was sort of, you know, you're taking like a futurist view of how artificial intelligence was going to affect the real estate industry.
Speaker AAnd my concept was kind of centered around 2001 A Space Odyssey with the HAL 9000 being like this omnipresent robot that is all over this spaceship.
Speaker AJust like omnipresent robots are existing in our homes now with your iPhone and the Nest thermostat.
Speaker AAnd there's so many these smart home things are starting to affect it.
Speaker AAnd so it's fun to even look back on that story because some of that stuff has not actually happened yet.
Speaker ABut a lot of it is starting to really come to fruition, the idea of artificial intelligence really impacting our industry.
Speaker AAnd when I go around to like when we would working for Reach in second century, we would encounter a lot of companies that said they used artificial intelligence, but not really.
Speaker ABut styledad, they started as an image editing company.
Speaker ASo they had, you know, for lack of a better word, like a ton of people who knew how to use Photoshop and they would declutter a listing photo or they would add some furniture to a listing photo.
Speaker AAnd in fact, styledad still does that, a lot of that.
Speaker ABut what they realized is that artificial intelligence is the next step for that, is that all of these things can be done with artificial intelligence.
Speaker ASo they doubled down learning how to use these models.
Speaker AAnd a lot of them are free, you know, from like ChatGPT and Alibaba.
Speaker AAnd so they figured out how to do a lot of that work with a robot.
Speaker AYou know, they.
Speaker AThey can declutter a picture very easily.
Speaker AThey can look at a picture and.
Speaker AAnd figure out what's in the picture very easily now.
Speaker ASo when they got into real estate, what they realized is that, or within the US Market is that a lot of this could really be helpful to an mls.
Speaker AAnd MLS have a tremendous amount of compliance issues that they deal with every day, which is why MLS data is the best data, because it's very likely to be accurate, because there's a whole team of people at the MLS making sure that the data is correct.
Speaker AAnd then there's all the other members of the MLS who complain when there is something that's not in compliance.
Speaker AAnd about half of the compliance issues these days are in the photos.
Speaker ASo in some mlss, you cannot have, for instance, a license plate on a car showing in the picture.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker ABecause it's a personal identification, or you can't have a person in there.
Speaker AAnd there's a lot of reasons for that, and that's pretty common.
Speaker AAnd there's almost always a person in the bathroom mirror when they're taking pictures of the bathroom.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker AAnytime there's a mirror, there's a person.
Speaker ASometimes you can't have animals like dogs or things like that.
Speaker AThe biggest one is real estate signs out in front front.
Speaker APeople take a picture of the real estate sign as a way to get around how the listings are done.
Speaker AOr they'll straight up put like a business card or information about how to get in touch with them directly in.
Speaker BThe photos of that granite countertop or something.
Speaker AYeah, yeah.
Speaker ASo, you know, so there was all these compliance issues that MLs have to deal with, and they realized that they could help the MLS do that.
Speaker AAnd so the last couple years, they've been working with CRMLs out of California who invested in them to come up with a great compliance tool that allows when you go to upload your images into the mls, instead of waiting for someone to complain and getting a fine or whatever, you know, the agent will immediately see that these three photos are out of compliance.
Speaker AAnd at the same time, because we are using artificial intelligence instead of someone with Photoshop skills, we have fixed the image already.
Speaker AAnd so we show them a preview of the fixed image.
Speaker ASo if there was a picture of the house out front There was a real estate sign.
Speaker AHere's a preview of what this picture will look like without a real estate sign.
Speaker AAnd then all you gotta do is give a couple credits and approve it.
Speaker AAnd then now the compliance team at the MLS no longer has to deal with that.
Speaker AThe agent doesn't have to worry about a fine.
Speaker AThe broker doesn't have to worry about getting a phone call.
Speaker AThere's, you know, there's, you know, it just like drastically avoids a lot of those compliance issues.
Speaker AAnd, you know, mls, they don't want to find their members.
Speaker BNo.
Speaker AYou know, like the last thing they do.
Speaker BNo, it's not, it's.
Speaker BIt's weird.
Speaker BThe people that pay you, you're going to, you know, take some of the, some more money.
Speaker BBut, but I get it.
Speaker BI mean, ultimately, if everyone else is playing by the rules and a few people aren't, you got to do something, right?
Speaker AAnd so this just sort of like avoids all of that.
Speaker AAnd then at the same time, we, because we're.
Speaker ANow we have those photos, we can make recommendations about, hey, this room would probably look a lot better with all, all this terrible furniture in it.
Speaker ASo for this many credits, you can take the furniture out here, you can take the rug out here, you can add hardwood floors here, you could add modern furniture if you wanted to.
Speaker ABut the tech is so good.
Speaker AI mean, it can look at a picture.
Speaker AIt knows that that window can't move.
Speaker AIt knows that this counter shouldn't move, but this bed can definitely go away.
Speaker AIt understands what a mirror is.
Speaker AYou know, it understands the reflections in the mirror.
Speaker AIt can take a picture of like a piece of furniture online and understand already what the 3D view of it is just based on pictures of thousands of other pieces of furniture.
Speaker ASo it's really, at some point it's gonna be very difficult to have humans do this work when robots could be so effective at it.
Speaker ARight now you get sort of a mixed output.
Speaker ALike this picture of the room might have furniture in this format and the next picture it might be slightly different.
Speaker ASo if you're trying to do a listing, like if you're a property owner or like a apartment buildings, you probably want to still hire a human to make sure all the pictures are uniform and look exactly the same.
Speaker ABut if you're a listing agent and you're just trying to show some furniture in an empty house, it's awesome.
Speaker AIt works great for that already.
Speaker AAnd it's just going to keep getting.
Speaker AJust in the few months that I've been there, it's gotten Better.
Speaker AIt's absolutely amazing tech.
Speaker AAnd the thing I like about it the most is that because we're building it in this way, it's really aligned with real estate agents, it's aligned with the mls.
Speaker AIt's not this controversial.
Speaker AYou know, I don't have to really be a punching bag at this company as opposed to, like, wow.
Speaker BPeople like, yeah, people like what we do.
Speaker BWe don't have to worry about it.
Speaker AThere's probably an offshore Photoshop person who's mad at us.
Speaker ABut otherwise, you know, it's very friendly to the real estate industry, and it just helps real estate agents and brokers be more effective and have less compliance issues, which I think 99% of the agents that ever have a compliance agent issue didn't mean it.
Speaker AYou know, they weren't intending that.
Speaker ASo, yeah, it's great tech.
Speaker BAll right, Todd, I'm kind of running short on time, you know, and I know I'm taking your time.
Speaker BSo I did want to find out with ccp, you know, where.
Speaker BWhere do you stand here?
Speaker BThere's some very, very big voices.
Speaker BJames Dwiggins, you know, has been really forefront with this with Next Home.
Speaker BWhat's your take?
Speaker AWell, my take is based 100% on anecdotal evidence.
Speaker AI had a compass agent when I purchased a house a few years ago, and that house was not on the MLS yet, and it was listed by a different compass agent.
Speaker AAnd turns out we got a steal on that house.
Speaker AAnd then when we went to sell it, we talked to the compass agent, and we talked to a different local agent.
Speaker AAnd the different local agent had an approach that I thought was better, that was, you know, maximum exposure, which from my Trulia days, I believe in.
Speaker AAnd we.
Speaker AWe made far more money on that house than I ever imagined.
Speaker AAnd so it seems like CCP is very good for a listing agent.
Speaker AAnd if you're the right buyer's agent, maybe the other way is better.
Speaker ABut I think overall, consumers are better served by maximum exposure.
Speaker AAnd that's just how I see it.
Speaker BI like that.
Speaker BThat makes sense.
Speaker BI have to ask you the same final question I've asked every guest since Jay Thompson, who was the first guest on this podcast.
Speaker BWhich is what one piece of advice would you give a new agent?
Speaker BJust getting started?
Speaker AYeah, I guess there was a.
Speaker ATom Ferry once said, if there was something you could go back and know more when just starting in the industry, what would it be?
Speaker AAnd I'd say I would want to know more people.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker AI think the real key to being an effective real estate agent is not like whether or not they understand AI or use social media or have a great CRM.
Speaker AIt's really that focus on your network and you have to be willing to leverage your network, ask for referrals, go to church, maybe not sell there, but you just end up knowing more people and people will refer you.
Speaker AAnd it's really all about your sphere of influence and banging away on those relationships.
Speaker APeople are the most important part about this industry.
Speaker BI love that answer.
Speaker BTodd, if someone wants to reach out to you, what's the best way for them to do that?
Speaker AYeah, you can find me on LinkedIn or I'm still on Twitter.
Speaker AI'm like five of us left but car on Twitter.
Speaker AToddyledod.com is my email.
Speaker AIf anyone would like to reach out and find out more about Styled, I'd be happy to talk to him.
Speaker BAwesome.
Speaker BTodd, this has been great.
Speaker BI was waiting for the TCAR moment because that's first of all, only four letters in a Twitter handle.
Speaker BHow did he do that?
Speaker BIt was awesome.
Speaker AApparently was early enough, but yeah, being early.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BBut yeah, this has been great.
Speaker BI really appreciate it.
Speaker BI hope to run into you somewhere around the country.
Speaker BI'm not doing as much back with fnf, but it's been wonderful chatting with you here and best of luck for you and the family.
Speaker BWe have a new addition arriving shortly, so congratulations on that.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd pleasure talking to you.
Speaker BThanks so much for doing this.
Speaker AAbsolutely.
Speaker ABill, it was great to talk to.